This study explores the experiences of alumni from the Dream Together Master (DTM) Global Sport Management Graduate Program, a fully funded master’s degree for professionals from low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). As an Official Development Assistance (ODA) supported Sport for Development and Peace (SDP) initiative, DTM offers an alternative to sport participation-focused models of SDP by investing in higher education for adult professionals. Drawing on in-depth interviews with 19 alumni, the research investigates motivations, professional and personal development, and post-program challenges. Findings show that DTM enhances expertise, career advancement, and personal growth; however, these individual gains do not always lead to systemic change, particularly in countries where sport is not a national priority. Some alumni also reported feeling positioned as passive recipients, reflecting power imbalances in donor-driven ODA-SDP structures. The study highlights the need for collaborative program design and strategic partnerships with local sport governing bodies in the LMICs to harness graduates’ expertise effectively. These insights offer a nuanced understanding of the relationship between ODA, SDP, and sport management education, and underscore the importance of sustained, context-sensitive approaches for supporting the long-term impact of international SDP initiatives.